Hans Zimmer’s ‘Dune: Part Two’ Score Disqualified from Oscars

Hans Zimmer’s score for “Dune: Part Two” has been disqualified from the 2024 Oscars. The Academy’s decision is based on the film’s heavy use of pre-existing themes from “Dune: Part One.”

Academy rules require that a score be predominantly original, with limited incorporation of pre-existing material, to qualify for the Best Original Score category. Zimmer’s “Dune: Part Two” soundtrack heavily builds on motifs established in the first film, leading to the score’s ineligibility.

Critical Acclaim Despite Disqualification

Despite the disqualification, Zimmer’s score for the second part of Dune has been widely praised. Critics admire his ability to expand the musical landscape set by the first film, deepening the emotional and narrative connections between the two parts. Many believe the sequel’s music surpasses its predecessor, with a richer and more intense atmosphere that perfectly matches the film’s darker themes.

Broader Impact on Awards Season

Zimmer’s disqualification removes a potential frontrunner from the awards race. It has sparked conversations about how the Academy’s rules might sometimes conflict with the creative choices that enhance sequels and cinematic universes.

Nevertheless, Zimmer’s contribution to the Dune saga has solidified his reputation as a master composer, even without Oscar recognition. His score remains a cultural achievement, demonstrating the power of continuity in cinematic music, and will likely continue to influence the soundtracks of future epic films.

This decision reshapes the Oscar competition, paving the way for other composers to take the spotlight.